Andromeda’s Edge, a spiritual successor to Dwellings of Eldervale, promises an epic sci-fi journey filled with resource gathering, ship battles, and civilization building. Designed by Luke Laurie and boasting a production packed with jaw-dropping miniatures and high-quality components, it’s a game that looks stellar. Unfortunately, beneath its shiny exterior, Andromeda’s Edge struggles to deliver the rewarding experience players might expect. Despite its sprawling mechanics and ambitious design, the game often feels like a grind with little payoff.
A Galaxy Brimming with Potential
The theme of Andromeda’s Edge is undeniably enticing. You lead a faction striving to establish a foothold in a wild and dangerous galaxy. The art and production scream “premium,” with detailed miniatures, modular boards, and colorful components that bring the Edge to life. From the precursor ruins to the eerie nebulae, the setting exudes sci-fi intrigue.
The sheer quantity of pieces—ships, moons, modules, and more—is impressive, creating a table presence that wows at first glance. The double-layered player boards and faction-specific upgrades demonstrate thoughtful attention to detail.
However, the thematic integration feels surface-level. While the game creates an illusion of narrative depth, the mechanics rarely align with the story. It often feels like you’re moving pieces for the sake of movement rather than advancing a cohesive tale. The galaxy may look alive, but its heart is missing.
Gameplay: A System Overloaded
Andromeda’s Edge combines multiple mechanisms—resource management, area control, dice rolling, and deck building—into a sprawling ruleset. Players take turns launching ships, claiming moons, upgrading stations, and building developments. Key mechanics include:
Faction Asymmetry: Each faction comes with unique abilities and ship upgrades.
Progress Tracks: Advancing on five tracks (science, industry, commerce, civilization, supremacy) dictates your rewards and end-game scoring.
Dice-Based Battles: Combat relies on dice rolls, introducing randomness to key conflicts.
While these elements sound engaging, the execution is cumbersome. The gameplay loop often feels bloated, with players performing multiple actions that lack synergy. The progress tracks—a central feature—rarely deliver a sense of accomplishment, making turns feel repetitive and unrewarding. The result is a game that’s less about strategic choices and more about mechanical upkeep.
Style Over Substance
Andromeda’s Edge dazzles at first but struggles to maintain its appeal. The sheer volume of components and rules can overwhelm newcomers, and even seasoned gamers may find the game’s pacing sluggish. Turns frequently drag as players optimize moves that don’t feel impactful.
Interaction between players is limited, often confined to battles and competition for planets. The dice-based combat can feel frustrating, especially when bad rolls undermine strategic planning. The modularity of the board adds replayability, but the core issues with pacing and reward mechanisms persist across games.
While the game accommodates various player counts, it feels most cohesive at higher counts (4-5 players). Solo and two-player modes lack the dynamic interplay that the game’s sprawling mechanics demand. Andromeda’s Edge may look like an epic adventure, but its gameplay often feels like busy work.
Final Reflections: A Misstep Among the Stars
Andromeda’s Edge is a visually stunning game that falls short of its potential. Despite its ambitious design and premium components, the game’s convoluted mechanics and lack of satisfying rewards leave it adrift. Fans of Dwellings of Eldervale may find echoes of its predecessor’s brilliance, but they’ll also notice the void where cohesive gameplay should be.
Who is this game for? Players who enjoy expansive sci-fi settings and don’t mind a slow, mechanical experience may appreciate the game. However, most gamers would be better off exploring other galactic adventures.
Final Rating: 5.5 out of 10
The Bottom Line: Andromeda’s Edge is a visual feast with gameplay that fails to match its ambition. A beautiful disappointment.
Check our Rating Scale here.
Want to check more? Take a look at the videos/reviews below:
- Watch the “How to Play” video on YouTube
- The Dice Tower Review
- Read the rulebook here.
Enjoyed this review? You can read our other reviews here: Reviews
