Archeos Society, designed by Paolo Mori, reimagines Ethnos with an archaeological theme. Players lead expeditions, collect cards, and advance along tracks to earn points. While it retains Ethnos’s core mechanics, this reimplementation lacks the charm and vibrancy of its predecessor, making it feel more mechanical and less engaging.
Losing Fantasy for Formula
Archeos Society trades Ethnos’s colorful fantasy setting for a subdued archaeological theme. While the premise of uncovering ancient artifacts is intriguing, the execution feels sterile. The tracks, representing excavation progress, are visually uninspired and lack thematic depth, turning what should be thrilling discoveries into mundane point calculations.
The components, though functional, fail to excite. The artwork is clean but lacks the personality and whimsy of the original. The muted color palette and repetitive track designs add to the game’s mechanical feel. While the thematic elements like relics and roles attempt to add flavor, they don’t integrate well enough to bring the theme to life.
This reimplementation’s presentation prioritizes practicality over vibrancy. The result is a game that feels more like an exercise in efficiency than an adventurous dig into the past. Fans of Ethnos may miss the charm and energy that made the original a standout.
Gameplay: Familiar Yet Flattened
Archeos Society retains Ethnos’s core card collection and set-building mechanics but introduces new elements, like advancing vehicles on tracks. Each turn, players:
Gain Cards: Players draw cards from a display or the deck, building their hand for future expeditions.
Play Expeditions: Players use matching cards to lead expeditions, advancing their vehicles along tracks or triggering role-specific effects.
Score Points: Progress along tracks and the size of completed expeditions determine players’ points at the end of each season.
While the mechanics are straightforward, the lack of interaction and the repetitive nature of advancing vehicles diminish the excitement. The tracks, intended to add strategic depth, often feel like a tedious exercise in optimization rather than an engaging race for discovery.
A Hollow Reimagining
Archeos Society delivers a functional but uninspired experience. The streamlined mechanics and limited interaction make it accessible but also less engaging for players seeking dynamic competition. The silent focus on individual progress reduces the sense of rivalry that made Ethnos so captivating.
Replayability suffers due to the game’s lack of variety. While different roles and tracks offer some variation, the core gameplay loop remains largely unchanged. The absence of Ethnos’s vibrant personalities and dynamic map interactions further weakens the overall experience.
Despite its accessibility, Archeos Society struggles to evoke excitement. Fans of Ethnos may find it difficult to connect with this reimplementation, as it replaces much of the original’s charm with a more mechanical approach. Newcomers, however, might appreciate its simplicity as a gateway game.
Final Reflections: A Step Backward
Archeos Society attempts to modernize Ethnos but falls short of recapturing its magic. The shift to an archaeological theme and the addition of tracks fail to enhance the experience, leaving a game that feels both uninspired and underwhelming. While it offers functional gameplay, it lacks the charm and excitement that made the original a gem.
Who is this game for? Players new to Ethnos or those seeking a streamlined, low-interaction game might appreciate Archeos Society. Fans of the original may be disappointed.
Final Rating: 6.0 out of 10
The Bottom Line: Archeos Society reimplements Ethnos with a functional but uninspired archaeological theme, losing much of the charm and dynamism of the original.
Check our Rating Scale here.
Want to check more? Take a look at the videos/reviews below:
- Watch the “How to Play” video on YouTube
- The Dice Tower Review
- Read the rulebook here.
Enjoyed this review? You can support Critical Cardboard by purchasing the game through our Amazon affiliate link. It won’t cost you extra, but it helps us keep creating great board game content. Thank you for your support!
Fantastic review!